
 
On Sunday night, the Mets announced their all-time 
team, which was comprised of the best players at each position 
throughout their half century of existence.  There were no surprises at 
certain positions.   For example, Keith Hernandez was voted the team’s 
best first baseman, David Wright took home the honor of top third 
baseman and Tom Seaver was the team’s best right-handed starting 
pitcher.  But when it came time to announce the team’s best manager, it 
came as a surprise to some people that Davey Johnson was named the top 
skipper over Gil Hodges.  I have one question to ask those people.  Why 
are you so surprised?
The
 people who disagree with the selection have made some good points in 
defense of their favorite field general.  They claim that Hodges changed
 the direction of the team, showing his players that they were good 
enough to win and that the team was far removed from the early “lovable 
loser” days of the franchise.  That is very much true.  Under Hodges’ 
leadership, the Mets went from a team that had lost 100 or more games in
 five of their first six campaigns (losing 95 in the other) to a World 
Series champion in two seasons.  In Hodges’ first year as the team’s 
manager (1968), the Mets improved from 61 wins to 73 wins.  It was the 
first time the team lost fewer than 90 games in a single season and set 
the stage for the Miracle Mets of 1969.
Those
 who favor Gil Hodges over Davey Johnson also point to Hodges’ impact on
 his players.  To this day, the men who played under Hodges get 
misty-eyed whenever they talk about his influence on them as individuals
 as well as his role in getting all of his players to use every ounce of
 their talent so they could perform to the best of their ability.
There
 is no question that Hodges was one of the best managers in Mets 
history.  After never finishing higher than ninth in the ten-team 
National League prior to Hodges’ arrival, the Mets soared to new heights
 under No. 14.  They surpassed 70 wins for the first time in 1968, then 
followed that up with a championship in 1969 and two third-place 
finishes in the six-team National League East in 1970 and 1971.  But 
despite the unprecedented success experienced by the Mets under Hodges, 
Davey Johnson was just as good, if not better.
Other
 than the 100-win campaign in 1969, no Gil Hodges-led Mets team won more
 than 83 games in a single season.  Meanwhile, no Mets team under Davey 
Johnson’s watch won fewer than 87 games.  Prior to Hodges’ arrival in 
1968, the Mets had finished in last place or next-to-last place in all 
six of their seasons.  Similarly, Davey Johnson took over a 
long-moribund Mets franchise in 1984 that had just come off its seventh 
consecutive finish in the NL East basement or knock-knock-knocking on 
the cellar’s door.
Tom
 Seaver had already won 16 games for a Mets team that only won 61 times 
in 1967, before Hodges was brought aboard.  Similarly, Jerry Koosman had
 already made his first appearance with the Mets prior to Hodges’ 
arrival, as did Cleon Jones, Buddy Harrelson, Jerry Grote and a handful 
of other key players that helped the Mets to the 1969 title.  Meanwhile,
 Davey Johnson brought Dwight Gooden with him from the minors, and was 
also instrumental in giving regular jobs and/or extended playing time to
 key members of the 1986 World Champions – players such as Wally 
Backman, Lenny Dykstra, Roger McDowell, Sid Fernandez and Kevin 
Mitchell.

 
Both won championships as managers, but only one deserves to be called the best in Mets history. 
Whereas 
Hodges had a similar cast of characters throughout his four-year tenure 
as Mets manager (this was prior to free agency), Johnson had to deal 
with a number of new players in his 6½ years as Mets’ skipper.  Johnson 
won 90 games in 1984 with Mike Fitzgerald as his catcher and Jose Oquendo and Ron Gardenhire splitting most of the time at shortstop.  On the mound, Walt Terrell, Bruce Berenyi, Ed Lynch, Mike Torrez, Tim Leary and Calvin Schiraldi combined to start more than half (83) of the team's games.  By 1986, the quintet of Dwight Gooden, Ron Darling, Sid Fernandez, Bob Ojeda and Rick Aguilera started all but 14 of the team's 162 regular season games.  However, by 1989, mostly everyone was gone or on their way out.
Wally Backman was traded to Minnesota after the 1988 season.  The following June, Terry Leach, Roger McDowell and Lenny Dykstra were also sent packing.  July saw the departures of Mookie Wilson, Lee Mazzilli and Rick Aguilera.  Finally, in November, Keith Hernandez was granted free agency and Gary Carter was released.  Despite the extreme roster turnover, Johnson still won 87 games in 1989, remaining in playoff contention until the final week of the season.
Injuries
 were also a major concern for the Mets during Johnson’s tenure.  In 
1985, Darryl Strawberry injured his thumb and missed seven weeks.  1987 was the year every starting pitcher missed time due to injury or 
drug rehab.  The Mets still managed to win a minimum of 92 games in each
 season.
Despite the 
injuries, the changes in personnel and the decline of veteran players 
such as Keith Hernandez and Gary Carter, the Mets never finished lower 
than second place in any full season under Johnson.  They entered the 
month of September either in first place or within striking distance of 
the division lead in all of Johnson’s seasons.  Other than 1969, 
no Gil Hodges-led team finished higher than third place.  The 1968 Mets finished 16 games under .500, the 1970 squad finished six games out of first and the 1971 team was never closer than 10 games out of first after the All-Star Break.
Lastly,
 let’s take out Hodges’ best season (1969) and Johnson’s best year 
(1986) from their records.  How did they both fare when the team wasn’t 
at its peak?  It’s not even close.  Hodges was eight games under .500 
(239-247) in his other three seasons as Mets manager.  Johnson was a 
whopping 124 games over .500 in his non-1986 seasons (487-363).
Gil
 Hodges had an outstanding year as Mets manager in 1969.  His leadership
 skills were certainly instrumental in taking the team from 
laughingstocks of the league to baseball nirvana.  But other than that 
miraculous season, the Mets were just mediocre at best.  Davey Johnson’s
 Mets were never mediocre in his six full seasons at the helm.  His 
teams were thrown curveballs from every angle.  Whether it was a drug 
suspension here or a rash of injuries there, Johnson always found a way 
to keep the team competitive deep into the season, and on two occasions 
(1986, 1988) well into October.  And he did that after taking over a 
Mets team that had not finished with a winning record since four years 
after Hodges’ untimely passing.
Although
 Gil Hodges did an exceptional job during his four years as the Mets’ 
field general, Davey Johnson earned the right to be named the team’s 
best manager over its first 50 seasons.  There should be no question 
about that one.